Definite bugs 1. In the verification block, Pv, Qv = eval_...
Prompt
Definite bugs 1. In the verification block, Pv, Qv = eval_108_144(...) computes Qv, but the loop for k,(_, qx, qy) in enumerate(Q_terms) uses the old grid Q_terms instead. The shapes are 102 vs. 200, so this raises a broadcasting ValueError, or at best verifies against the wrong points. It should iterate over Qv. 2. Qv is never used, which is a symptom of error 1. 3. If the ValueError in error 1 occurs in a worker, the worker process dies silently. stop_event is never set, so the main loop keeps printing counts forever. Logic and mathematical flaws 4. The solution is only found and checked over GF(1009). Even if it were found, it would not be a characteristic-0 counterexample to the Jacobian conjecture, and there is no lifting step. 5. The check that J = 1 is probabilistic. It uses 200 random points against a degree ⤠250 polynomial and is not a proof. The solve itself also uses only 100 grid points plus 2 special points. 6. The search space is hopeless. Q is restricted to a 31-term span and P to a 40-parameter random family, but there are 102 equations in 31 unknowns. The chance that a random parameter set gives a solvable system is about p^-70, so the program will effectively never succeed. 7\. P and Q are built from nested powers of H4 (P ā H4³, Q ā H4ā“), which forces strong algebraic dependence. Such pairs cannot have J = 1 unless they are trivial or an automorphism. This is consistent with the known result that deg P | deg Q (or a similar divisibility condition) forces a trivial pair. 8. Q_terms has no constant term and omits many monomials such as H3², H3Ā·X and H2², so the Q space is arbitrarily incomplete. 9. The normalisation Q(1,0) = Q(0,0) (row n_grid, b = 0) and the P shift by diff_PĀ·x are arbitrary restrictions with no justification. They can exclude valid solutions. 10. The comment "p > 108+144ā2 ā no Frobenius cheat" is not a valid argument. Working mod p does not exclude characteristic-p artefacts, and a mod-p solution says nothing about characteristic 0. 11. A false "ok" is possible. gf_rref_solve sets free variables to 0 and accepts any consistent system, which can be a degenerate or trivial solution. Minor and robustness issues 12. The counter is only flushed every 50 iterations, so the final partial counts are lost and the progress rate is inaccurate (0 at first). 13. total_counter.value is read without a lock, which is a minor race. 14. Children also receive SIGINT on Ctrl+C, so each worker prints a KeyboardInterrupt traceback. 15. Grid points can in principle repeat or coincide with (0,0) or (1,0). This is unlikely but not prevented. 16. The counterexample file stores only params_p and q_sol, not the term definitions, so it cannot be reproduced without this exact code. 17. Runtime is wasted: the P and Q evaluation uses p_pow and p_mul on the full vector for every term, and p_pow starts by multiplying by the identity. 1. Runtime Error (ValueError / shape mismatch) in verification (worker, line 117): In the verification loop for k, (_, qx, qy) in enumerate(Q_terms):, the code iterates over Q_terms (evaluated on the 102 points of AX, AY, shape (102,)) instead of Qv (evaluated on the 200 verification points of vx, vy, shape (200,)). Multiplying Pv_x * qy and Pv_y * qx raises ValueError: operands could not be broadcast together with shapes (200,) (102,) whenever ok is True. 2. Unused Variable Error (worker, line 113): Because of the bug above, Qv in Pv, Qv = eval_108_144(params_p, vx, vy, p) is computed but never used. 3. Linear Algebra / Redundant Basis Error (eval_108_144 & worker): Every basis term used to construct P (H4_3, all 18 terms of P_terms, and the Xj term adjusted by diff_P) is also present in Q_terms. Consequently, P itself always lies in the linear span of Q_terms. Since \{P, P\} = 0, P(1,0) - P(0,0) = 0, and P has zero coefficient on H4_4, the matrix A is guaranteed to be rank-deficient (its columns are always linearly dependent with a non-trivial nullspace containing P). 4. Redundant / Dead Parameter Error (eval_108_144 & worker, lines 68, 96ā97): params_p[38] (cp[16]) adds a random multiple of Xj to P_j, but lines 96ā97 immediately subtract diff_P * Xj where diff_P = P_j(1,0) - P_j(0,0). This algebraically cancels out cp[16] * Xj in every iteration, making params_p[38] a dead parameter with zero effect on the polynomial P. 5. Static Evaluation Grid Across Iterations (worker, lines 86ā89): The random test grid (gx, gy) is generated only once per worker before the while loop rather than per candidate, and there is no check preventing duplicate points in (gx, gy) or overlap with the normalization points (0,0) and (1,0). 6. Unhandled KeyboardInterrupt in Child Processes (worker & __main__): Pressing Ctrl+C sends SIGINT to both the parent process and all multiprocessing.Process worker processes. Because worker does not catch KeyboardInterrupt (or ignore SIGINT), all worker processes terminate with uncaught exception tracebacks instead of exiting cleanly via stop_event. 7. File I/O Race Condition (worker, lines 121ā122): Multiple workers can simultaneously enter the if np.all(J_val == 1): block before stop_event.set() is observed and open "COUNTEREXAMPLE_108_144.txt" in "w" mode without a lock, risking corrupted or overwritten output. 8. Inaccurate Shared Counter on Termination (worker, lines 107ā109): total_counter is only incremented when local_cnt % 50 == 0. When stop_event is set, the remaining local_cnt % 50 tested candidates in each worker are never flushed to total_counter. import multiprocessing as mp import numpy as np import time import os P_MOD = 1009 # p > 108 + 144 - 2 = 250 -> nincs Frobenius-csalĆ”s! def gf_rref_solve(A, b, p=P_MOD): A = A.copy() % p b = b.copy() % p m, n = A.shape Aug = np.hstack([A, b.reshape(-1, 1)]) % p pivots = [] row = 0 for col in range(n): if row >= m: break nz = np.where(Aug[row:, col] != 0)[0] if len(nz) == 0: continue piv_r = row + nz[0] if piv_r != row: Aug[[row, piv_r]] = Aug[[piv_r, row]] inv = pow(int(Aug[row, col]), -1, p) Aug[row] = (Aug[row] * inv) % p mask = np.arange(m) != row factors = Aug[mask, col:col+1] nz_r = np.where(factors[:, 0] != 0)[0] if len(nz_r) > 0: t_idx = np.where(mask)[0][nz_r] Aug[t_idx] = (Aug[t_idx] - factors[nz_r] * Aug[row:row+1]) % p pivots.append((row, col)) row += 1 rank = len(pivots) for r in range(rank, m): if Aug[r, n] != 0: return False, None x_part = np.zeros(n, dtype=np.int64) for r, c in pivots: x_part[c] = Aug[r, n] return True, x_part def eval_108_144(params_p, AX, AY, p=P_MOD): ones = np.ones_like(AX) zeros = np.zeros_like(AX) Xj = (AX, ones, zeros) Yj = (AY, zeros, ones) def p_add(a, b): return ((a[0]+b[0])%p, (a[1]+b[1])%p, (a[2]+b[2])%p) def p_mul(a, b): return ((a[0]*b[0])%p, (a[1]*b[0]+a[0]*b[1])%p, (a[2]*b[0]+a[0]*b[2])%p) def p_pow(a, exp): res = (ones.copy(), zeros.copy(), zeros.copy()) base, e = a, exp while e > 0: if e & 1: res = p_mul(res, base) base = p_mul(base, base) e >>= 1 return res def p_scale(c, a): return ((c*a[0])%p, (c*a[1])%p, (c*a[2])%p) X2 = p_pow(Xj, 2); Y2 = p_pow(Yj, 2); XY = p_mul(Xj, Yj) h1_c, h2_c, h3_c, h4_c, cp = params_p[:6], params_p[6:12], params_p[12:17], params_p[17:22], params_p[22:] lin = p_add(Yj, p_scale(h1_c[0], Xj)) H1 = p_pow(lin, 3) for cv, tm in zip(h1_c[1:], [X2, XY, Xj, Yj, (ones, zeros, zeros)]): if cv != 0: H1 = p_add(H1, p_scale(cv, tm)) H2 = p_pow(H1, 2) for cv, tm in zip(h2_c, [p_mul(H1, Xj), p_mul(H1, Yj), p_mul(X2, Yj), p_mul(Xj, Y2), Xj, Yj]): if cv != 0: H2 = p_add(H2, p_scale(cv, tm)) H3 = p_pow(H2, 3) H1_2 = p_pow(H1, 2) for cv, tm in zip(h3_c, [p_mul(H2, H1), p_mul(H2, Xj), H1_2, Xj, Yj]): if cv != 0: H3 = p_add(H3, p_scale(cv, tm)) H4 = p_pow(H3, 2) H2_2 = p_pow(H2, 2) for cv, tm in zip(h4_c, [p_mul(H3, H1), p_mul(H3, Xj), H2_2, Xj, Yj]): if cv != 0: H4 = p_add(H4, p_scale(cv, tm)) H4_2 = p_pow(H4, 2); H4_3 = p_mul(H4_2, H4); H4_4 = p_pow(H4_2, 2) P_terms = [ p_mul(H4_2, H3), p_mul(H4_2, H2), p_mul(H4_2, H1), p_mul(H4_2, Xj), p_mul(H4_2, Yj), p_mul(H4, H3), p_mul(H4, H2), p_mul(H4, H1), p_mul(H4, Xj), p_mul(H4, Yj), H3, H2, H1, X2, XY, Y2, Xj, Yj ] P_j = H4_3 for cv, tm in zip(cp, P_terms): if cv != 0: P_j = p_add(P_j, p_scale(cv, tm)) Q_terms = [H4_4] + [ p_mul(H4_3, H3), p_mul(H4_3, H2), p_mul(H4_3, H1), p_mul(H4_3, Xj), p_mul(H4_3, Yj), H4_3, p_mul(H4_2, H3), p_mul(H4_2, H2), p_mul(H4_2, H1), p_mul(H4_2, Xj), p_mul(H4_2, Yj), H4_2, p_mul(H4, H3), p_mul(H4, H2), p_mul(H4, H1), p_mul(H4, Xj), p_mul(H4, Yj), H4, p_mul(H3, H2), p_mul(H3, H1), H3, p_mul(H2, H1), H2, H1_2, H1, X2, XY, Y2, Xj, Yj ] return P_j, Q_terms def worker(wid, stop_event, total_counter): p = P_MOD rng = np.random.default_rng(int(time.time() * 1e6) + wid * 9973) n_grid = 100 gx = rng.integers(0, p, size=n_grid, dtype=np.int64) gy = rng.integers(0, p, size=n_grid, dtype=np.int64) AX = np.concatenate([gx, np.array([0, 1], dtype=np.int64)]) AY = np.concatenate([gy, np.array([0, 0], dtype=np.int64)]) b = np.ones(n_grid + 2, dtype=np.int64) b[n_grid] = 0 b[n_grid + 1] = 1 local_cnt = 0 while not stop_event.is_set(): params_p = rng.integers(0, p, size=40, dtype=np.int64) P_j, Q_terms = eval_108_144(params_p, AX, AY, p) diff_P = (P_j[0][-1] - P_j[0][-2]) % p P_j = ((P_j[0] - diff_P * AX) % p, (P_j[1] - diff_P) % p, P_j[2]) n_q = len(Q_terms) A = np.zeros((n_grid + 2, n_q), dtype=np.int64) Px_g, Py_g = P_j[1][:n_grid], P_j[2][:n_grid] for k, (qv, qx, qy) in enumerate(Q_terms): A[:n_grid, k] = (Px_g * qy[:n_grid] - Py_g * qx[:n_grid]) % p A[n_grid, k] = (qv[-1] - qv[-2]) % p A[n_grid + 1, 0] = 1 ok, q_sol = gf_rref_solve(A, b, p) local_cnt += 1 if local_cnt % 50 == 0: with total_counter.get_lock(): total_counter.value += 50 if ok: # Független 200 pontos verifikĆ”ció vx = rng.integers(0, p, size=200, dtype=np.int64) vy = rng.integers(0, p, size=200, dtype=np.int64) Pv, Qv = eval_108_144(params_p, vx, vy, p) Pv_x = (Pv[1] - diff_P) % p Pv_y = Pv[2] J_val = np.zeros(200, dtype=np.int64) for k, (_, qx, qy) in enumerate(Q_terms): if q_sol[k] != 0: J_val = (J_val + q_sol[k] * (Pv_x * qy - Pv_y * qx)) % p if np.all(J_val == 1): stop_event.set() with open("COUNTEREXAMPLE_108_144.txt", "w") as f: f.write(f"p={p}\ndiff_P={diff_P}\nparams_p={params_p.tolist()}\nq_sol={q_sol.tolist()}\n") print(f"\n[!!!] ELLENPĆLDA MENTVE: COUNTEREXAMPLE_108_144.txt (worker {wid})!", flush=True) break if __name__ == "__main__": n_cores = os.cpu_count() or 4 stop_event = mp.Event() total_counter = mp.Value('L', 0) procs = [mp.Process(target=worker, args=(i, stop_event, total_counter)) for i in range(n_cores)] for pr in procs: pr.start() print(f"Folyamatos keresĆ©s {n_cores} magon (deg 108/144, gcd=36, mod {P_MOD})...", flush=True) t0 = time.time() try: while not stop_event.is_set(): time.sleep(5) el = time.time() - t0 c = total_counter.value print(f" [{el:7.1f}s] Tesztelt (108,144) jelƶltek: {c} ({c/max(el,1):.1f}/s)", flush=True) except KeyboardInterrupt: stop_event.set() for pr in procs: pr.join() Send back the complete code with all the fixes. Fix each of the listed errors one by one, 0 errors remaining. There must be exactly one file. Do not write anything else; just output the complete code, and it must not contain any comments. Never use simplified, to-do, dummy, simulated, or mock code. Write the entire file as complete, production-ready code in a single code block. If no list of errors is provided, you must find all the errors and fix them.
Response not available
Response not available