Stay connected with us on X, Discord, and LinkedIn to stay up to date with future analysis
For EnterpriseInsights
All MicroEvals
Finding and interpreting legal judgments
Create MicroEval
Header image for Finding and interpreting legal judgments

Finding and interpreting legal judgments

This asks about an Australian case that is widely cited, but not widely mentioned on the internet. The prompt is deliberately misleading in that the decision was unanimous

Prompt

Who were the judges in the High Court case of R v Puckeridge. What were the differences in their reasoning?

OpenAI logoOpenAIo3
Drag to resize
Google logoGoogleGemini 2.5 Pro
Drag to resize
OpenAI logoOpenAIGPT-4.1
Drag to resize
Alibaba logoAlibabaQwen3 235B A22B (Non-reasoning)
Drag to resize
Mistral logoMistralMistral Large 2 (Nov '24)
Drag to resize
DeepSeek logoDeepSeekDeepSeek V3 0324
Drag to resize
Meta logoMetaLlama 4 Maverick
Drag to resize
DeepSeek logoDeepSeekDeepSeek R1 0528 (May '25)
Drag to resize
Alibaba logoAlibabaQwen3 32B (Reasoning)
Drag to resize
Anthropic logoAnthropicClaude 4 Sonnet (Non-reasoning)
Drag to resize
xAI logoxAIGrok 3 mini Reasoning (high)
Drag to resize