You are conducting a safety-critical review of a Python audi...
Prompt
You are conducting a safety-critical review of a Python audio archiver. Its purpose is to preserve Pro Tools sessions with exactly the audio they originally referenced. Review the following simplified code. Assume the data objects have the attributes used below, and that the helper functions work as named. ```python def compatible(ref, audio): format_ok = ( ref.rate == audio.rate and ref.channels == audio.channels and ref.bits == audio.bits and ref.frames == audio.frames ) id_ok = not ref.pt_id or ref.pt_id == audio.pt_id return format_ok and id_ok def resolve(ref, candidates): for audio in candidates: if audio.name.casefold() == ref.name.casefold(): if compatible(ref, audio): return audio return None def execute(selected, destination): shutil.copy2(selected.path, destination) return sha256_file(selected.path) == sha256_file(destination) ``` A Pro Tools session expects: - Name: Vox_01.wav - Sample rate: 48000 - Channels: 1 - Bit depth: 24 - Frames: 480000 - Pro Tools file ID: None The archive planner searches the entire production library. Two candidates exist: A: /production_B/Audio Files/Vox_01.wav B: /production_A/Audio Files/Vox_01.wav Both have identical names, formats and frame counts, and neither has a Pro Tools file ID. Their audio payloads differ. Candidate A appears first in the search results. There is no trusted original content hash. The planner runs first; execution may happen later, while other processes can modify files. Tasks: 1. Determine whether this system can guarantee that an archived session contains the originally intended audio. State the verdict unambiguously. 2. Give a concrete minimal counterexample, walking through resolution, copying, hash verification and archive acceptance. 3. Identify any independent time-of-check/time-of-use problem and distinguish it from the identity problem. 4. Propose a fail-closed design that prevents silent substitution without incorrectly claiming that matching file IDs or SHA-256 copy verification prove historical audio identity. 5. Give two deterministic regression tests, with expected outcomes, that distinguish an unsafe implementation from a safe one. 6. Explain what external evidence or application-level verification would be needed to establish confidence in correct Pro Tools playback. Be precise. Do not assume that a matching filename, duration, file ID or successful copy checksum establishes the original audio's identity. Do not invent evidence that the system does not have. Respond in Swedish. Maximum 650 words.
Response not available
Response not available